We ended up adding a high top brown wicker table with turquoise and dark brown cushions. It filled the space nicely and the cushions were the same base fabric as our original set, but the color scheme was not quite complimentary.
I had this solved though. My solution - use pillows to tie the color schemes together. But there was a sticking point - I'm good at making pillows, I am bad at choosing fabrics.
This is where my luck kicks in - as a thank you for sharing my pillow techniques earlier this year - my friend Anne, of DeCocco Drapes fame gifted me with a gorgeous set of fabric samples. Better than that, the color scheme of her samples married my turquoise and peach color scheme beautifully.
Do you think they did their job in making my porch furniture appear to be a planned set of contrasts versus the mismatched hodge podge it started out as?